Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nick Felker's avatar

Structurally it seems odd that journals are still organized as periodic papers stitched together. It would be better in a digital system for a study webpage to have an addendum underneath that includes links to replications under the same journal for better organization.

Who really is out there reading every single item published by a journal? And who will stop doing that if they occasionally publish a replication?

Expand full comment
Suryanarayana GS's avatar

The system of replications reducing the impact factor should be done away with unless the original paper is adjudged as outright fraud. Since the replication is also research, replications of non-fraud papers should also be counted for estimating impact factors.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts